By strange coincidence (with the author of the original post in this thread), I sold my 2015 Ducati Multistrada 1200S Touring at the beginning of this season. Nothing wrong with it. Definitely an (if not "the") apex predator of the ADV category (for on road performance, at least). But there were two issues for me that weren't going to get better. One, it's far too much bike for the street. It's like giving pony rides on a thoroughbred. Two, it wasn't my motorcycle soul mate, and life's too short not to find one.
So, I tested a ton of bikes. I won't go into them all, but I thought the Speed Twin was going to be the one. It seemed like the perfect blend of standards like the T100/T120 Bonneville and sportier cafe racers like the Thruxton R. And on paper it's a star: lightweight, Brembos, Thruxton engine, 17" front tire for more "flickability." When I tested it right before my second ride on a T120 — and it proved to be well tuned, solid and precise feeling — I thought it'd be too tough an act to follow. But then I got on the T120 (again), and it just...wasn't.
The Speed Twin struck me as a wonderfully well-sorted machine, but it didn't charm me the way the T120 did. Where the Speed Twin was taut, with abundant engine breaking and the like (logical, for a sportier machine), the T120 was unstressed and just glided down the road like a familiar dance partner. This also came through in the more relaxed riding position and the "plantedness" and stability that comes with greater weight and that 18" front wheel. As I've said many times, it's easy for a bike to be fun going fast, harder to be a joy going slow. The T120 is a bike that lets you slow down to smell the roses, not the need to blow them off their stems as you pass by.
And when you do spot that too-inviting stretch of curvy road that begs for extra, unlike many cruisers, the T120 obliges. The torque, street-appropriate power, exhaust "note" and confident (if not racer) handling make it a pleasure when the pace picks up.
If I lived on the side of one of California's famous canyon roads, I might choose differently. But for the riding I'm able to do, this type of bike that prioritizes character, comfort and cruising is the ticket to maximum contentment. That's why I bought a T120 less than a month ago and it's been bliss. There are tweaks to be made, but it's by far the best bike I've spent time on.
And, it's worth noting that nowhere above did I mention looks, nostalgia, how Triumph did such a brilliant job making the engine look like its mills of old. That's because, while I think "retros" are generally appealing, I have no particular affection for them, nor am I trying to capture some vision from my childhood. I wasn't alive in the 50s-60s.
Certainly, it's subjective and personal, but not a single bike I tried had the T120's magic mix of character/soul and refinement.