Thruxton fender eliminator kits

My brother just bought an 05' Thruxton and wants to purchase a fender elim kit. He's looking at both the newthruxton.com kit @ http://www.newthruxton.com/html/fender_eliminator_kit.html and also the british-customs kit @ http://www.british-customs.com/store/triumph-motorcycle-parts-accessories/british-customs-fender-eliminator-kit.html

We both think the british-customs kit is alot cleaner looking but wondering which kit is better. the newthruxton kit comes with a protective piece and not sure about the bc kit. Which one is the better of the two. We can always use the bc kit and purchase the protective cover seperately.

thanks
chris