I have one. I didn't replace a screen, I bought the bike as a wreck and it didn't have one so I can't compare. I got a real deal on the GIVI. I have, since installing the screen, modified my mirrors and added a secondary/extension/airfoil made out of 1/16 Lexan to the screen to try and reduce the notorious buffeting. I really enjoyed all the warning stickers that came on the screen. It sounds like if you park the bike outside, the screen wil focus the sun on the bike and burn it up! Maybe this is an American thing - lawyers are everywhere! - but so far I've had no fires and I live in the Arizona desert!