Triumph Rat Motorcycle Forums banner

Gas tank breather hints and tips

65K views 43 replies 27 participants last post by  Forchetto  
#1 · (Edited)
Having tried out a new Indian restaurant here in my home town, and not having had a curry since last time I visited the UK, I made an erroneous choice from the menu: A fiery Prawn Vindaloo. My digestive system is now indicating this was unwise and I have been sitting in the bog all morning...I think Johnny Cash wrote a song about it: Ring of Fire...

I thought I use my sojourn in the bathroom to write something to bore you all with, but mainly to help some newbies that have trouble with the gas tank breather and, judging by the frequent posts, it's a lot.

In the good old days the gas tank breather system consisted of nothing more complicated than a tiny hole in the gas cap that allowed air to flow into the tank as the gas was used up. If no air can get in no gas can flow out. These holes could sometimes get blocked up and the cure was simply to poke something sharp into it or blow them out.

Today things are a little more complicated due to certain safety and emission laws. For example gas caps are not allow to vent raw gas fumes into the atmosphere. To avoid this they have no breather hole at all. There's a spring loaded valve in their centre but this is a blow-off valve that opens only under certain pressure if the gas tank becomes pressurised by expanding gas and fumes. In some States of the US these caps are tested (on cars at least) as part of regular inspections and, I believe, even replaced free of charge if they fail the blow-off test.

The part that lets air in nowadays is a separate system that fulfills three roles: To vent the tank, to allow excess fuel to overflow to the ground rather than spill over the tank and on to a hot engine, and to close off the flow of gas out of the tank in the event of an accident causing the bike to tip-over.

In certain States, (California for example), this system is further complicated by the requirement that all raw gas fumes expelled during engine off conditions are captured in a charcoal canister and then released back into the engine at pre-set conditions and intervals.

Testing the breather

To test the operation of this breather system disconnect the hose from the gas tank (it's towards the rear right hand side). This hose has no clips but it fits very tightly on a long metal stub welded to the tank. You can feel for it by running your hand around the right hand edge of the tank, towards the rear just ahead of the carb. On EFI models extra care is required to ensure you don't disturb the right hand MAP sensor hose that lives near by.

Image


It can be difficult to disconnect without lifting the tank. Before replacing it smear some silicon-based grease on the stub to ease fitting and future removal. I say silicon grease because ordinary petroleum-based lubricants tend to rot rubber components.

Tools required: Simply your mouth and lungs.

First test:

You should be able to blow down it as much as you like and should feel clear if there's no obstruction.

Second test:

You should also be able to suck on it normally without feeling any
obstructions, but if you increase suction you should feel it block up. This is the Roll-over valve operating.

This valve has a little ball that blocks the outflow of fuel if the bike is laid over to prevent fuel spillage and risk of fire. The strong suction you can create even with your mouth brings the ball into operation blocking the suction.

The valve looks like a small black plastic cylinder about 2" long with an "UP" marked on it to indicate the correct position, it must be positioned upright. It is sited just in front of the airbox, close to the top of the crankcase.

Image


If there's an obstruction in the hose and you can't blow or suck through it then there are three possible reasons:

1/ The hose is trapped or pinched somewhere under the tank or along its path around the frame.

2/ The roll-over valve is faulty. Perhaps the ball is stuck in the closed position. This can happen if you regularly ignore owners manual instructions not to over-fill the tank beyond a certain level. The breather system then acts as an overflow when the fuel expands due to heat and some fuel remains inside the valve. The evaporation of this fuel leaves behind a varnish or gum-like residue that can cause the ball-valve to stick in the closed position.

3/ The hose is blocked somewhere along its length by road debris, water or even gas that has drained down from an over-filled tank and got stuck in there.

Disconnect the first section of hose from the top of the tip-over valve and blow through it. It should be clear. If so then the blockage is either on the valve or the short length of hose that goes from the bottom of the valve to a point under the bike by the swing arm pivot tube.

A good tip for avoiding future problems with this short hose is to locate where it exits by the swing arm pivot area and practice a long slash cut on the end with a craft knife. As standard it comes cut flat right across. Do the cut so it faces towards the front of the bike, this way the airstream will suck the hose clear.

This is an oversight by the Factory (slash-cut drain and breather hoses are common on Jap bike) as even a drop of water can block the exit and cause fuel starvation symptoms. A slash cut prevents this for some obscure scientific reason I dont understand...something to do with venturi effects or meniscus or
something with a silly word in it...:).

If you go on to post number 11, Verde has kindly supplied a couple of photos illustrating how this is done.

Quite a few posters have experienced fuel starvation problems following a ride in the rain due to water blocking this hose so it's worth doing that slash-cut.

On California models this hose terminates in the EVAP charcoal canister and there's very little I can tell you about that as I don't know the system.

Here's a last drawing ilustrating the breather components common on the whole range, except California models with the EVAP system.

Item 21 is the long hose from tank to roll-over valve, 22 is the roll-over valve and 25 the short hose to atmosphere:

Image
 
#2 ·
A good tip for avoiding future problems with this short hose is to locate where it exits by the swing arm pivot area and practice a long slash cut on the end with a craft knife. As standard it comes cut flat right across. Do the cut so it faces towards the front of the bike, this way the airstream will suck the hose clear.
.........................................................
Quite a few posters have experienced fuel starvation problems following a ride in the rain due to water blocking this hose so it's worth doing that slash-cut.
Although your description is of a fuel injected bike, is this likely to happen to a UK / carbed bike without the roll over valve etc?

The reason I ask is that I've had a series of breakdowns recently after riding in heavy rain. My assumption was that the coils had got wet, so I dried them off as best I could and got it restarted, but only on one cylinder. It eventually restarted on both cylinders, then cut out again after another few miles.

While it was running on one, just for the hell of it I pulled the plug lead off the dead cylinder and heard sparking inside the plug cap, which led me to wonder if my problem was fuel, not electrics. It occurred to me that the carbs had iced up due to humidity / temperature / pressure drop in the venturi, but it may be simpler than that...
 
#6 ·
Same system is fitted to both carbed and EFI bikes, so yes, it applies to both. I believe the roll-over valve was fitted to all models. At least it's shown on the spares list from 2001 onwards.

Your breakdowns could be due to the things you mention. It depends on wether the bike cut out suddenly or sort of fizzled out and lost power slowly. In the first instance it points to an ignition fault, very possibly water in the coils. These are in a very exposed position and we've had lots of posts about that. Dielectric grease in all the connections is usually prescribed and some have reinforced the waterproofing by sheathing the coil in some sort of rubber sleeeve or jacket.

I thought Bonnevilles all came with thermostatically-controlled carb heaters that come on at low temperatures. If yours hasn't then Carb icing can happen, even in Europe. The combination of cold, damp air and the cooling effect of fuel vaporization can build up a sort of "Ice collar" in the venturi that slowly strangles the engine.

Upon stopping, scratching your head, lighting up a ciggie, etc the ice melts due to engine heat and the trouble disappears...the perfect crime as the crime weapon is never found.
 
#5 ·
Having tried out a new Indian restaurant here in my home town, and not having had a curry since last time I visited the UK, I made an erroneous choice from the menu: A fiery Prawn Vindaloo. My digestive system is now indicating this was unwise and I have been sitting in the bog all morning...I think Johnny Cash wrote a song about it: Ring of Fire...
:laughhard
 
#7 ·
All the carb bike uses is a tube in the tank that goes into the filler neak below the gas cap its wide open .The tube hooks to a hose that goes to the bottom of the bike at the end of it is the tip over valve.On never carb bikes this hose goes into the canster at the bottom of the bike that most people throw away any way.So in fact the carb bike is the same as haveing a vent hole in the tank top .
 
#9 ·
Yes, in effect the system is still breathing fumes to the atmosphere except on California models with their EVAP systems.

The thing is that at least on mine, the gas cap is sealed except for the blow-off valve and it relies for the breathing on the hose/roll-over valve combination. I've put up another drawing in the original post to show the components.
 
#8 ·
The connections to the coil terminals are 'greased' and tight. The boot around the HT lead wasn't particularly well fitted, so I pushed it on better and ty-rapped it for a firm fit. There is no grease on the HT terminals.

I had another breakdown in similar conditions subsequent to going over the connections, fortunately the engine cut out as I rolled in to work. It started and ran fine when I went back to it later.

The multipin connector on the igniter module doesn't have 'greased' contacts, I will get some grease to seal that connector.

It did lose power (running on one) before stopping completely.

Wonder if the carb heaters aren't working?

From my triple days, I recall that coils were prone to failing if they got warm, wouldn't wrapping them in a sleeve just re-create that problem?

Apologies for thread drifting.
 
#15 · (Edited)
A word about carb icing, for those that have never had it happen ...

The first misconception is that the weather doesn't need to be freezing for carbs to ice up. All that is needed is humid air and a cool temperature. The venturi in the carb causes a drop in air pressure which makes the temperature of the fuel mix to drop considerably, and moisture in the 'air' part of the mix can form into ice crystals, which can block the passages and give all the symptoms of fuel starvation - anything from slight rough running up to a stopped engine. As you throttle off, the heat from the engine will melt the ice - sometimes after a few minutes, sometimes before the bike has even stopped. One way you know it's carb icing rather than anything more serious is that the bike will always run again after a short stop.

It's a bit of a mystery (at least to me) because I have run many carbed bikes through many winters and never had it, and then had bikes that will do it as soon as the leaves start falling from the trees. My Bandit 1200 used to do it frequently, from October through to about March. Carb heaters don't always cure it - the Bandit was also the only bike I have had (apart from the Bonnie) that had them.
 
#17 ·
I slash cut my vent tube last year; but I have the open part of the slash facing to the rear, thinking that would more likely create a wee vacuum to help suck the air down. No problems so far.

Why is it recommended to have the cut facing forward? I'd think that would be more likely to 'push" air into the hose.
 
#19 ·
Oh, good onyas. After reading all this yesterday, I've dove under my bike with sidecutters, and cut the 2 tubes to face forwards. Should've waited a bit. Oh well, lucky there's still plenty of hose length to play with, should somebody come up with the right answer. Havin' fun messin' with my brains? Next project, Bobbin' the kids' pushbikes.
 
#20 ·
Maybe I'll re-do mine with the slash to the side just to get the best of both worlds:p

Honestly cant remember who said slash facing forward first, but I've just been going with it since 'cause it's been working. On the carb breather you don't want pressure going in either direction, that's what causes a lot of the surging or sputtering problems reported. The end being high enough up to be well shielded by the engine and not dangling in the breeze is the most important part. I wouldn't worry too much about which way the slash is, so long as it's there. It would be nice to know that there isn't a slight pressure lending to a tendency for fine dust to go UP the tubes though... Anyone got an air pressure meter they can strap on the bottom of their bike and i.d. the ultimate breather tube termination point?:rolleyes:
 
#22 ·
Forchetto, I'm not so sure I will ever again be able to read one of your very informative posts without picturing you.. umm.. disposing of a Vindaloo. Thanks. :eek:≈≈
 
#23 ·
Oh, but I think the direction of the slash has less impact than the fact that simply cutting at an angle opens up a larger hole....
 
#25 ·
Reviving this thread for a midwest heat-wave question:

Having removed the AI and Cal-evap canisters, I find that when the bike has been sitting in the hot sun for a couple hours, gasoline is dripping out of the vent tube. I assume with the direct radiant heat on the black tank, it increases the vapor pressure inside the tank, and the vapor then condenses in the relatively cooler tube.

Thoughts on how to prevent this? Or should I just be sanguine about it?
 
#27 ·
I guess I'll accept is as a charming eccentricity. It's only happened twice so far -- both times in direct sun on asphalt over 90deg. I briefly considered just capping it, but of course that would prevent air coming in to replace the fuel being used, creating a vacuum, etc. etc.

I could also try to park in the shade, or paint the tank white.
 
#30 ·
Use a catchcan under this fuel tank overflow/vent hose!!

I suggest to anyone who rides these bikes fairly hard to put this hose into a catchcan.

When the fuel tank is 3/4 or more full, under heavy braking for a left hand corner fuel can slosh out of this breather line onto the rear tire, especially dangerous if powering hard out of a left hand corner.

How do I know? Recently crashed on my own fuel!!
Warm day, tires were hot, corner was free of gravel and oil
Sorted this out temporarily by blocking the fuel tank overflow/vent line with a bolt.

Probably a good idea to have the carb breather hose in to a catch can as well.

Initially when i bought this bike, i had the vapour lock problem, engine running rough and shutiing down like it was out of fuel.... pull the fuel cap apart, there is a small plastic disc in the fuel cap that covers the fuel cap vent valve, removed this cap and removed the flat wound spring that acts on the fuel cap vent valve, refitted the plastic disc, put fuel cap back together.
Vapour lock problem solved!!
The combination of the spring tension on the fuel cap vent valve and the rollover valve cased this vapour lock problem.

Cheers.....Agro
 
#31 ·
Carb icing. Reminds me of a really old tale, 30's 40's. Winters night, guy riding along, comes across a fellow motor cyclist stopped at side of road. There they are, huge "footing" macs, gauntlets, scarfs, goggles hats and suchlike. The rescuer says "Have you tried peeing on the carb" Shake of the head. "OK" says our hero, and does just that. Great, bike fires up, away they go.

Couple of days later, our hero is chatting to a local copper and mentions the episode. "Ah, thanks for that" says the copper, "That was my daughter"


I said it was old.
 
#32 ·
Can I just delete the roll over valve...

I got rid of the emissions in stages, as I re worked through the POs half assed delete. The last to go was the charcoal canister (I'm in CA) but the tube that went to it was super long and twisty and kinked.

Before I got rid of it I suffered from some stumbling, and a few stalls - in case you are thinking about it, I would generally recomennd refraining from stalling in LA traffic.


I need to go for a better shake down to make sure but it seems to pull better than ever !

At this point I am thinking less is more… and would like to get rid of the valve altogether - is there a reason, besides an actual tip over to keep it?