I use BelRay chain lube. It works great and does not sling off.
I never said that the Scotoiler didn't work as intended, I simply said I have never seen on fitted to a clean bike.
I understand that there are many who like the Scotoiler, I'm just not one of them. My bike is more than simply transportation to me. I enjoy it looking nice and I'm not out to set any records on how long I can make a chain last. The people at D.I.D have got to eat too.