I have to say that both sides of the arguement make great points! All my life (30 years) I've been addicted to anything that has 2 wheels. My first motorcycle was an 1975 yamaha yz 80 (I was about 6 years old) I rode a lot in the dirt as a kid and had zero restraint on motorcycles. As far as I was concerned they should have had push buttons for a throttle mechanism. when I was about 18 I had a hard crash on my RT 180 and hurt my back, no broken bones but I still have a spot in my back that gets sore pretty easily. I fixed the bike and sold it, and put motorcycles aside for quite awhile. I bought a downhill mountain bike and rode it like a madman for a few years, crashing and learning and getting faster (it's pretty amazing how fast you can go on a bicycle down a steep mountain) Finally one day the inevetible happened, I got a chance to ride a big bore two stroke dirt bike. Tons of power at hand! I found that I had developed the ability to practice self control riding a motorcycle again (and this thing demanded that you did) I bought a 1995 Honda XR650L and spent a summer re-familiarizing myself with the mechanics of riding a motorcycle. Then I got a chance to try out street riding on a suzuki 500 GS (with a learners permit) It was slow, didn't corner well and I still loved it. I only logged about 1000KM on it and decided I needed to get a bike of my own.
I did a ton of research and decided that I didn't want to fork out a ton of money going through the progression of little bike, intermediate bikes and then the liter bike.
My FIRST street bike is my 2002 Sprint RS 955i, I've ridden it about 11000KM to date and respect every ounce of power it has. I started out riding fairly conservatively on it and spent a LOT of time practicing slow speed manuevers in parking lots on it. It is very well behaved when it comes to power delivery. I think the only way that I could get the front tire off the ground would be to give her lots of throttle input and let the clutch out hard. I've found that the power has actually been a huge benefit to my learning curve. I've been in a couple of situations overtaking traffic where the gap in traffic I intended on occupying closes after I pull out to pass, I simply downshift and roll the thottle on hard and pass a few more cars (of course watching very carfully for the idiot that pulls out unexpectadly in front of me) The brakes are equally helpful, if there isn't enough room I can shut it down and merge back in quickly too.
The key is to practice self restraint, learn the machine in a safe environment, and use common sense. If there is advance training available in your area take advantage of it and sign up. There are a lot of great techniques to learn and I know that I have a lot more to learn. I plan on taking some advanced courses as soon as I find some available near by. I'm learning by riding with responsible seasoned riders who know my limits and have good advice.
If you feel that you can do those things and have enough skill to ride a heavier bike then go for it! but be carefull and don't push your limits, in fact stay well within them. If you buy an RS and it has the Bridgestone BT020's on it get rid of them ASAP (Mine had them and I rode them for a season, but really didn't trust them) I replaced the factory tires with Michellin Pilot road CT2S tires and it has made a world of difference. I just recently dragged a Peg for the first time and the bike was totally hooked up! Very confidence inspiring tires indeed
