I've not had much luck in the past with glove purchases.
I've tried silk inserts on my everyday gloves: great feel but after an hour I can't feel my left hand.
I've tried the big bulky gloves: warmth for hours but zero feel.
Then, a friend turned me on to First Ascent Guide Gloves. Bought them online at Whittaker Mountaineering.
Great feel and warmth. Had them out today in Nashville in 40 degree weather and they rocked.
Thought i would share.