This is what I built for my 05 Speed Triple.
It is .125 aluminum (that's 1/8 inch or 11 Gauge) and painted black. Should re-do it and get it anodized. I had a similar one on two different bikes and neither one ever cracked.
.125 aluminum will never break under the kind of vibration on a motorcycle. I use to build stuff (professionally) out of both .125 and .063 (1/16 or about 16 Gauge) aluminum for heavy trucks and it took a severe amount of abuse to crack them just through vibration.
What kuhlka has built is in my opinion severe overkill, but nice. What you must remember is when you start adding bracing like he did you reduce the flexibility of the metal. This makes it prone to cracks at the stress points. A simpler piece of metal with only one bend will flex and act as a spring. This tends to reduce the amount of cracking.
OTOH, what kuhlka has built is so over-engineered that it will probably never crack short of an accident. Here's hoping that it never happens.
What nthn_specl has made looks to be made out of either .063 aluminum, or more likely .050 to my eye (which is pretty good). If it's .050 then I agree it's probably too light and will break easily. You would probably get away with .063 or .100 but .125 would be best.
[ This message was edited by: crashmasterd on 2006-01-07 21:52 ]