Most motorcycle batteries are warrantied for at least six months - wouldn't hurt to try that route before springing for new battery. You might end up with a new spare anyway!
Common reasons for new battery failure:
Improperly handled at initial charge;
Manufacturing defects, bad cell(s), dropped;
Too high charge (most mc bat's take about 1AH trickle);
Faulty wiring on bike (alarm, accessories, etc.);
Repeated excessive power drain;
Less commonly suspected faulty charger burning batteries...
More reasons on
Yuasa FAQ.
You might want a new charger made for motorcycle batteries in case your old charger's faulty/ too high amp hour rate (AH). Faulty chargers can burn batteries during only one use. Any name brand motorcycle specific charger will do.
I've seen bike battery chargers burn out on car batteries, inversely, car battery chargers burn out bike batteries.
Hope this helps!