IMHO, the best thing to do with that old semi is to donate it to someone running an old Harley or Triumph, as they go through LOTS more oil than we do!

Seriously, the fully synthetic oil tends to clean as well as lubricate, which accounts for the nasty looking first oil change for those folks who have switched over from mineral based. Semi shouldn't produce as much sludge and crud as 100 percent mineral, but if I were going to be cheap (sorry, frugal) and use up the old stuff, I would alternate oil changes with the Amsoil. That way, your seals won't take a hit and start leaking (which would be rare), and any increase in deposits would be flushed out by the next Amsoil change. You can have your cake and eat it too!