I've tested all the oil that has been in my (new model) Bonnie -- I run the same oil that you do. It is probably not any better or worse than all the rest, but it is 1/3 the price.
My oil reports point more with the miles on the oil as the issue - the longer you run the oil, the thinner it gets (broken down) By about 2500 miles, the oil goes down one grade, i.e., a 40 weight has the properties of a 30 weight. Beyond 3000 miles, the 40 weight was almost the same as a 20 weight in one of my reports.
I run the 50 weight so that when it starts to break down, I'm still (almost) covered. Also know, the heavier your oil, the less performance - things like mileage will be affected.
If you are at all interested in seeing my reports, go to
www.reallycooldude.com/oil1.pdf -- increment up on the number to see later reports. I have 5 or 6 total reports there. Covers Mobil1, Rotella, and Castrol.