I am assuming that you are also posting this in the Suggestions forum that Shawn watches pretty closely. He will make the call so be sure to get your opinion to him by posting it there.
Personally, what you say has a certain logic, but the fact is that if we split out all the Trumpet Twin cruiser riders we will lose some of my favorite posters. I LIKE those guys and would hate to lose contact with them. I know that it doesn't HAVE to happen and I can hang around over there with them too. But, over time, and not too much time at that, someone will say, "Hey, Monte, what are you doing over here? Don't you have your own forum?"
So what we have got may not be so logical, but it is nice for me the way it is. As for the Cafe forum I see no reason why it couldn't be folded in here if that is what its users really want to do.
Shawn has good instincts about such things, is always willing to listen and I will respect whatever he decides. Truth is, whether I respect it or not, it is his decision.
Monte